P4 Maths: Word problems: supposition, excess and shortage
What word problems: supposition, excess and shortage questions test at the level of the hardest P4 end-of-year papers, the mistakes that cost marks, and a question to try with its working.
This topic paper can't be started on its own now. The free P4 paper tests word problems: supposition, excess and shortage with the rest of the syllabus: create a free account to sit it, with a full report.
Where the marks go in supposition word problems
Supposition and excess and shortage are the heuristics P4 papers use for their hardest word problems. Assume every item is the cheaper one, then correct; or share two ways and compare what is left over and what is short.
The mistakes to look for
- Dividing by the price of one item instead of the difference in prices
- Taking the difference of what is left over and what is short, when one way leaves some over and the other runs short (they add)
- Answering with the other item's count
Try a question on word problems: supposition, excess and shortage
Question 11 (2 marks). Some pupils are sitting on benches in a hall. If 3 pupils sit on each bench, 12 pupils have no seat. If 4 pupils sit on each bench, 1 bench is left empty and the other benches are full. How many pupils are there?
- 16
- 48
- 60
- 51
Show the answer
(3) 60
With 4 on each bench, the empty bench has 1 × 4 = 4 seats not used.
Going from 3 to 4 a bench seats the 12 pupils with no seat and leaves 4 seats unused: 12 + 4 = 16 more seats.
Each bench gives 1 more seat, so there are 16 benches.
Pupils: 3 × 16 = 48, and 48 + 12 = 60
Start with a free paper
A free account opens a full Maths paper at P4, P5 and P6, marked the moment it's handed in, with every mistake explained.